Best Fireplace Grate – Cast Iron and Steel

Are you looking for the best fireplace grate?  Fireplace grates are an absolute necessity for every fireplace.  Not only do they keep the firewood in place, but they also help to increase airflow.

And, this is important because you want to maximize your wood-burning experience.  When you use a grate, it will increase the burn-time of the firewood, increase the heat output and produce a cleaner burning fire.

So, what should you look for in the best fireplace grate?  Well, first, material is important.  And, the best materials for a fireplace grate are steel and cast iron.

best fireplace grate

And that poses the next question, which is better?  Steel or cast iron?  According to DenGarden, steel fireplace grates are less efficient and generally do not last as long as cast iron.  However, if you choose a steel fireplace grate in a heavier-grade, it can last as long as cast iron.

Furthermore, stainless steel fireplace grates are typically used for wood only.  The bars of the grate are spread apart wider, and therefore, they are not able to accommodate coal.  So, if you’re looking to build a fire with coal, a cast iron fireplace grate is the best way to go.  This is because most cast iron grates have small divides which can accommodate coal without the coal falling through the gaps.

Another quality you should look for in the best fireplace grate is weight.  The heavier the grate, the better off you will be in the long run.  Heavy grates tend to be more durable and more fire retardant.  So, if you choose a fireplace grate above 20 pounds, it is going to last you a while.  And, the heavier the grate you choose, the more years of use you can tack on.

Furthermore, it is important to note that fireplace grates come in all sizes.  So, in this case, if you’re going with a small fireplace grate, a weight of 17 pounds is still going to be a medium-duty grate and will be durable enough for years to come.  But, if you’re an everyday fire starter, we do suggest going with a heavier weight than that.    

Finally, if you’re looking for some fireplace tools to go along with your fireplace grate, check out our picks for top fireplace tools here

   

Best Fireplace Grate

 MaterialSpecsPrice
Grate Wall of Fire Model M-6 High Efficiency Smoke-Free Fireplace Grate
Grate Wall of Fire
Model M-6 High Efficiency Smoke-Free Fireplace Grate
Steel
Cast Iron Finials
26" x 15"
Liberty Foundry HY-C G500-24 Sampson Series Cast Iron Fireplace Grate
Liberty Foundry
HY-C G500-24 Sampson Series Cast Iron Fireplace Grate
Cast Iron20" x 16"
24" x 16"
18" x 16"
20" x 20"
20" x 14"
Heritage Products Heavy Duty Steel Fireplace Grate
Heritage Products
Heavy Duty Steel Fireplace Grate
Steel18" x 14"
24" x 14"
27" x 14"
33" x 14"
36" x 14"
Amagabeli Black Wrought Iron Fireplace Log Grate
Amagabeli
Black Wrought Iron Fireplace Log Grate
Cast Iron22" x 11"
24" x 11"
Liberty Foundry HY-C G22-4 G-Series Franklin Style Cast Iron Fireplace Grate
Liberty Foundry
HY-C G22-4 G-Series Franklin Style Cast Iron Fireplace Grate
Cast Iron17" x 12" x 6.7"
22" x 12" x 5"
22" x 12" x 6.5"
27" x 12" x 6.5"
Uniflame Hexagonal Fireplace Grate
Uniflame
Hexagonal Fireplace Grate
Steel24" x 24"
27" x 27"
30" x 30"
36" x 36"

 

Best Fireplace Grate

Grate Wall of Fire Model M-6 High Efficiency Smoke-Free Fireplace Grate

Grate Wall of Fire Model M-6 High Efficiency Smoke-Free Fireplace Grate

Our first pick for best fireplace grate is a high-efficiency option that increases heat output.  The Grate Wall of Fire Model M-6 High Efficiency Smoke-Free Fireplace Grate not only increases heat output, it eliminates smoke output inside the home.

This fireplace grate works by resting on the rear wall of the fireplace.  Simply place the wood between the wall and the grate and you will have a clean burning fire in no time.

The Grate Wall of Fire High Efficiency Fireplace Grate is made with heavy-duty steel construction and comes with decorative cast iron finials which are removable in case the design doesn’t match your decor.  And, the steel constructed bars are .75 inches of solid steel.  

This fireplace grate measures 26 inches wide, 14 inches deep and 15 inches tall.  Therefore, the back wall of your fireplace needs to measure at least 26 inches wide and the depth of the fireplace should be at least 16 inches deep.  Furthermore, the entry to the fireplace should have enough depth so you’re able to load the firewood.

Pros:

The Grate Wall of Fire High Efficiency Fireplace Grate gets absolute rave reviews.  The most appreciated aspect of this fireplace grate is the amount of heat it delivers.  It will deliver a lot of heat in a short amount of time, which is perfect for those cold winter nights.

In addition, this fireplace grate eliminates smoke from coming into the house.  And, for those of us that have that issue, this fireplace grate is a lifesaver.

Cons:

Because this fireplace grate leans up against the back of the fireplace, it can cause brick and mortar failure overtime.  The solution to this is, The Grate Wall of Fire offers a reflective fireback to protect the wall from heat damage.  This fireback not only protects the rear of the fireplace, it is reflective, so therefore, it will reflect heat back into the room.  And, just like that, this fireplace grate just became even more efficient.  You can find the reflective fireback here.

Liberty Foundry HY-C G500-24 Sampson Series Cast Iron Fireplace Grate

Liberty Foundry HY-C G500-24 Sampson Series Cast Iron Fireplace Grate

This next pick for best fireplace grate is another high-efficiency option.  The Liberty Foundry HY-C G500-24 Sampson Series Cast Iron Fireplace Grate is designed in a way which allows you to combine wood with coal and receive air from all angles.  And, this allows the fire to burn cleanly while increasing the heat output.

This fireplace grate is made with heavy-duty cast iron and features removable 2.5 inch tall legs.  However, if you need to remove them for more clearance, this fireplace grate is extremely stable on its own.

Lastly, the Liberty Foundry Cast Iron Fireplace Grate comes in your choice of 5 different sizes:  20 inches by 16 inches, 24 inches by 16 inches, 18 inches by 16 inches, 20 inches by 20 inches or 20 inches by 14 inches.

Pros:

First of all, this fireplace grate is extremely attractive.  Most consumers can’t get enough of how well this fireplace grate presents itself.

Furthermore, this grate is made of solid cast iron and is extremely sturdy.  So, if you’re going to burn coal, this grate is up the challenge.  If you just want to burn wood, this is a great alternative to some of the steel fireplace grates which are designed in this same classic fashion.

Cons:

A few consumers felt the assembly is difficult and the instructions are hard to understand.  Patience is advised.

Heritage Products Heavy Duty Steel Fireplace Grate

Heritage Products Heavy Duty Steel Fireplace Grate

This next pick is designed to use for wood only.  The Heritage Products Heavy Duty Steel Fireplace Grate features a wide construction with wide-set bars.

This fireplace grate is made with heavy-duty steel construction with .375 inches by 1 inch thick bars.  And, having bars this thick, you won’t have to worry about warping.  

The Heritage Products Heavy Duty Steel Fireplace Grate is tapered to ensure it fits most fireplaces.  And, for added assurance on getting the right fit, this fireplace grate comes in your choice of sizes:  18 inches by 14 inches, 24 inches by 14 inches, 27 inches by 14 inches, 33 inches by 14 inches and 36 inches by 14 inches.

Pros:

This fireplace grate is heavy and durable.  And, when it comes to heavy-duty steel, this grate will last you a long time.

Furthermore, it comes in an array of sizes, enough to accommodate just about every fireplace out there.

Cons:

Every once in a while we review a product where we can find no defect.  And, as much as we tried to pick this fireplace grate apart, we couldn’t find one thing wrong with it.

 

Amagabeli Black Wrought Iron Fireplace Log Grate

Amagabeli Black Wrought Iron Fireplace Log Grate

This pick for best fireplace grate is designed to be used for wood only.  And, this grate is made with wrought iron, as opposed to cast iron.  So, it’s not going to be as durable as cast iron, but it is made with thick construction and will handle a lot of heat.

The Amagabeli Black Wrought Iron Fireplace Log Grate features 7 steel bars within a v-shaped rack.  This rack is processed with electroforged grating which seals up cracks, increasing durability.

This fireplace grate comes in your choice of 2 sizes:  22 inches long and 11.25 inches wide or 24 inches long and 7.5 inches wide.  Both sizes are a good weight at approximately 20 pounds.

Pros:

The Amagabeli Black Wrought Iron Fireplace Log Grate is heavy-duty and durable enough to handle an outdoor firepit.

Furthermore, it features a classic design and will blend well in just about any room or in any yard.

Cons:

Because it is made of wrought iron as opposed to cast iron, this may not be durable for an everyday fire starter.  It would last you a while, but probably not as long as a cast iron fireplace grate would.

Liberty Foundry HY-C G22-4 G-Series Franklin Style Cast Iron Fireplace Grate

Liberty Foundry HY-C G22-4 G-Series Franklin Style Cast Iron Fireplace Grate

The best aspect of this fireplace grate is it’s all one piece.  The Liberty Foundry Franklin Style Fireplace Grate is made with one solid piece of cast iron and sits on 4-inch cast-on legs.

And, this grate can burn both coal and wood because it is made of cast iron and designed with smaller gaps. 

The Liberty Foundry Franklin Style Fireplace Grate measures 12 inches deep and is designed for smaller fireplaces. It comes in your choice of lengths:  17 inches, 22 inches or 27 inches.

Pros:

Because this fireplace grate is made with heavy-duty cast iron, it is going to last through a lot of fires.

Additionally, this is a perfect size for smaller-sized fireplaces and works also great for an outdoor firepit.

Cons:

The legs on the Liberty Foundry Fireplace Grate are rather short, which is great for low-ceiling fireplaces.  However, because the legs are short, it doesn’t get as much airflow underneath and the coal accumulation can suffer because of it.

Uniflame Hexagonal Fireplace Grate

Uniflame Hexagonal Fireplace Grate

Our final pick for best fireplace grate is designed for wider fireplaces.  In addition, it is also designed in a hexagon shape for maximum airflow.

The Uniflame Hexagonal Fireplace Grate is constructed with 100% stainless steel with a black finish.  And, because it is stainless steel with wide set bars, this fireplace grate is for wood only.

The Uniflame Hexagonal Fireplace Grate comes in your choice of 4 different sizes:  24 inches by 24 inches, 27 inches by 27 inches, 30 inches by 30 inches and 36 inches by 36 inches.

Pros:

This fireplace grate is solidly built and extremely durable.

Additionally, the hexagon design is a brilliant feature because it allows for a whole lot of airflow.  And, this means more efficient burning time.

Cons:

The legs of the Uniflame Hexagonal Fireplace are rather short.  So, this deters some coal buildup which tends to extend the life of the fire.

Furthermore, this fireplace grate is not designed for outdoor use.

More Great Buys

One thought on “Best Fireplace Grate – Cast Iron and Steel

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *