Choosing the best popcorn popper is no easy chore. There are all types of different poppers on the market. Some are electric, some are microwavable, some are stove top and some look as if they come straight from the circus. Therefore, we chose the top rated popcorn poppers in each category.
So, what did we look for when we searched for the best popcorn popper? Well, reliability is a must. When we want popcorn, we want it now. And, there’s no room in our cupboards for a broken down popcorn machine.
The next aspect we look for in the best popcorn popper is convenience. Popcorn, for us, is one of those things we don’t want to spend a lot of time on. Usually, when we decide to have popcorn, it’s a split-second decision right before we snuggle up to watch a movie. Therefore, quick and convenient popcorn also topped our list.
So, after narrowing down the most reliable, quickest and most convenient popcorn poppers, we sifted through hundreds of user reviews and we found the top 6 best popcorn poppers on the market. And now all you have to do is choose which one is right for you.
But, which type of popcorn popper is best for you? Like we stated earlier, we have chosen the best Air, Microwave, Electric and Stove Top poppers and there’s a stark difference between all of them. So, if you’re undecided which one to go with, at the end of this post you will find a “Popcorn Popper Buying Guide” which will take you through the ins-and-outs of each type of popper.
However, If you know what you want, check out are top picks for best popcorn popper below.
Best Popcorn Popper
Best Air Popcorn Popper
Excelvan Homemade Air-Pop Popcorn Maker
Our first pick for best air popcorn popper offers a 2-n-1 solution. The Excelvan Homemade Air-Pop Popcorn Maker starts off as an air popper and converts to a popcorn bowl. So, once you finish popping the corn, the bowl detaches from the popper and you can just snack on the popcorn from there.
The Excelvan Homemade Air-Pop Popcorn Maker is made of plastic with a stainless steel liner. And, these materials are 100% BPA and melamine free. Therefore, this popcorn popper doesn’t include all the toxins you find in a lot of other plastic products.
This air popper will pop the popcorn quickly and easily. Simply feed the corn into the popper and it pops right into the bowl. In addition, because this is an air popper, the Excelvan Air-Pop Popcorn Maker doesn’t require oil in order to pop. This makes this pick for best popcorn maker one of the healthiest on our list.
Once you’re finished popping one batch of popcorn, it is recommended to let the air popper sit for 15 minutes before popping another batch. And, this is to ensure the popper doesn’t overheat.
The Excelvan Homemade Air-Pop Popcorn Maker collapses into 4 separate parts. This makes this air popper easy to clean and easy to store. However, this air popper is not dishwasher safe so you will have to clean it by hand.
Lastly, this air popper comes in your choice of 2 colors: Orange and White.
We like this pick for best popcorn maker because it is made with 100% BPA and melamine-free materials. In addition, the inner liner is constructed of stainless steel which is a very safe metal to cook with.
Furthermore, the Excelevan Homemade Air-Pop Popcorn Maker makes fantastic popcorn and it has a bowl you can pop with and eat out of.
With this popper, you can only use it in 15 minute intervals. So, if you’re feeding a large group of people, this may not be your most time efficient choice.
In addition, this popper is not dishwasher safe so you will be cleaning it by hand. The good news is, it does break down into 4 different pieces, making it rather easy to clean by hand.
Aicok Popcorn Maker
This next pick for best air popcorn popper is ultra fast. The Aicok Popcorn Maker is ready within minutes and has a popping rate of a whopping 98%. So, for every 100 kernels, 98 of them turn into popcorn.
This air popcorn popper is FDA approved and BPA free. Therefore, you will be popping with non toxic plastic for an even healthier bowl of popcorn.
The Aicok Popcorn Maker is easy to use. Simply use the included measuring spoon to fill the popcorn maker with corn. Close the cover and turn on the machine. And, within 2 minutes, you have a bowl of popcorn ready to go.
This pick for best popcorn popper is not machine washable. However, the base of this popcorn machine can be wiped down and the top cover and measuring cup can be hand washed.
This is another pick which is BPA free. So, this will make an even healthier bowl of popcorn.
Furthermore, for the price, this is one quick machine.
The Aicok Popcorn Popper can only pop so much popcorn at a time. And, in between sessions, you need to wait 10-12 minutes to let the machine cool down. So, this is a great pick for a small-sized family. A large family, not so much.
Best Microwave Popcorn Popper
HOTPOP The Original Microwave Popcorn Popper
Our pick for best microwave popcorn popper can pop up to 15 cups of popcorn within 4 minutes. Therefore, if you’re feeding a large family, this pick is extremely time efficient.
The HOTPOP Original Microwave Popcorn Popper is BPA free and PVC free. And, it is made with 100% food grade silicone.
This microwave popcorn popper allows you to add oil or do without. So, if you’re one of those who love to slather your kernels with oil, go for it. If you’re on a health kick, you don’t need oil to get these kernels popping.
The HOTPOP Microwave Popcorn Popper is a 2-n-1 solution. You can pop the kernels in the bowl and use the bowl for consuming the popcorn. Furthermore, the bowl has cool-touch handles so you can enjoy as soon as the last kernel is done popping.
This pick for best popcorn popper is dishwasher safe. And, once it’s clean and dry, you can collapse the bowl down to 2.4 inches tall to wedge it in the fullest of drawers.
Finally, the HOTPOP Microwave Popcorn Popper comes in your choice of 7 colors: Aqua, Black, Blue, Clear, Green, Purple and Red.
Like one consumer stated, “Can’t stop eating popcorn.” And, that pretty much says it all. However, we will elaborate. This popcorn popper makes popcorn super quick and it’s extremely easy to use. In addition, it’s pretty hard to burn the popcorn so expect every batch to be perfectly popped.
A few more notable features we love about this popper: it is BPA free, PVC free, it has cool touch handles, it collapses for easy storing and it doubles up as a bowl once you’re done popping. And, overall, we are highly impressed with this microwave popcorn popper.
A few consumers complained that this pick for best popcorn popper didn’t pop the popcorn all the way. However, the less kernels you use, the better your results will be.
Best Electric Popcorn Popper
West Bend Stir Crazy Electric Popcorn Popper Machine
For those who prefer an electric popcorn machine, the West Bend Stir Crazy Electric Popcorn Popper Machine is the way to go. This pick for best electric popcorn popper can pop up to 27 cups of popcorn in under 4 minutes.
This electric popcorn popper features a built-in butter well which will allow the popper to evenly coat your popcorn with butter. However, it is important to note that with this electric popcorn popper, you don’t need butter or oil to get the job done. Therefore, this is a healthy option when it comes to the popping world.
The West Bend Stir Crazy Electric Popcorn Popper is a 2-n-1 solution. Once the popcorn is done popping, the top lid converts to a bowl. And, this top lid is see-through, so you will be able to see the process unfold while you’re waiting. Furthermore, this bowl has heat-resistant handles. So, once the popcorn is done popping, you can dig right in.
And speaking of heat-resistance, this electric popcorn popper features a heat-resistant base to help protect your countertops from heat damage.
For cleaning purposes, this electric popcorn popper has a non-stick surface which makes cleanup a breeze. Simply wipe down the surface and you can throw the serving bowl in the top rack of the dishwasher.
Last, but definitely not least, the serving bowl is BPA free.
This pick for best popcorn popper is a great solution for those looking to feed a group of people as it pops 27 cups in less than 4 minutes. However, if you’re looking to use this for just a few cups of popcorn, this will work as well.
In addition, the built-in butter well is a great feature as it will evenly coat the popcorn to your liking. And, the fact that you don’t have to use the butter well is another nice feature.
Some consumers have complained this popcorn leaves a lot of condensation on the popcorn. What happens is this air popper produces steam while popping, and once done, when flipping the popcorn popper over and removing the bowl, the steam leaves the popcorn damp. It is important to note that most consumers didn’t have this issue. However, it may be a case of letting the popcorn sit for a bit and allowing the steam to settle.
In addition, some consumers have had issues with the non-stick coating scraping off. And, this is a bit concerning as you don’t want to be ingesting the non stick coating! But, again, most consumers didn’t seem to have this issue, so it may be a default with the particular popcorn popper they received. Our parting words, proceed with caution.
Best Stovetop Popcorn Popper
Great Northern Popcorn Company Original Stove Top Popcorn Popper
Our last pick for best popcorn popper is all about keeping it simple. And, sometimes simple is better. However, just be aware, it’s going to take a little work on your part.
The Great Northern Popcorn Company Original Stove Top Popcorn Popper is a classic popcorn machine where you will manually stir the popcorn while it’s popping. And, while this turns some people off, for others, it can feel like you’re a part of the process. Furthermore, it’s fantastic for toning up the arm.
This pick for best stove top popcorn popper is made of stainless steel and has a duplex heat pad to ensure even cooking. In addition, it comes with metal gears, as well as, wood handles and knobs.
The Great Northern Popcorn Company Original Stove Top Popcorn Popper will make 20 cups of popcorn in minutes. So, if you’re feeding a large family, this is a great solution to consider.
And, it is important to note that this popcorn popper will require oil in order to pop. Therefore, if you’re looking to feast on “naked” popcorn, you may want to try one of the other picks on our list.
Finally, this pick for best popcorn popper is one of the easiest to clean. It’s so easy you may forget all the work you did to stir the kernels. Just wipe the pan down with a paper towel and it’s ready to store.
The Great Northern Popcorn Company Original Stove Top Popcorn Popper is the real deal. It is built with stainless steel and real wood handles. Therefore, expect this popcorn popper to handle all the torment of popping popcorn for years to come.
Furthermore, it is a great solution for those looking to treat a lot of people as it will make up to 20 cups of popcorn in just minutes.
This pick for best popcorn popper is not to be used on an induction stove.
In addition, some consumers state the stirring rod doesn’t reach to the bottom of the pan far enough. Consequently, this leaves a lot of kernels yet to be popped.
Popcorn Popper Buying Guide
Like we mentioned above, there are stark differences between Air, Microwave, Electric and Stovetop popcorn poppers. And, we’ve mapped out a detailed buying guide to showcase the differences between these poppers and help you make the best decision for you.
Air Popcorn Popper
Popping popcorn via the air popper has been deemed the healthiest way to consume this snack. And, as Today suggests, it is the healthiest as long as you make “naked” air-popped popcorn. Naked air-popped popcorn is popping just the kernels and nothing else. However, most of us like to dress our popcorn with something. Therefore, after air popping the popcorn, you can control how much butter and salt you dress it with. So, with a light salty buttery seasoning, you can still be somewhat healthy with the air popcorn popper.
Using an air popcorn popper is easy. You just feed the kernels into the popper and within a couple of minutes you’ll have a bowl full of popcorn. And, to get a general idea of how an air popper works, our friends over at Instructables have a great guide detailing the process.
Microwave Popcorn Popper
A microwave popcorn popper is the easiest way to pop popcorn. And, it is also the least messy. Furthermore, with our pick for best microwave popcorn popper, it is just as healthy as using an air popcorn popper. This is because you can pop the corn without oil and add your desired amount, if any, after the popcorn is in its edible state.
So, if you’re looking for the most hassle-free way to pop corn, we suggest going the microwave route.
Electric Popcorn Popper
With most electric popcorn poppers, you will need to use oil while the kernels are popping. However, with the best electric popcorn popper on our list, you can pop with or without oil.
So, why would you go with an electric popcorn popper over the other options? And, it all comes down to preference. Furthermore, some people prefer to have their popcorn continuously stirred for them throughout the process.
Another reason why you may consider an electric popcorn popper is it will pop the most amount of popcorn in the shortest amount of time. So, if you’re looking to treat a larger group of people, this is definitely the route to take.
To get an idea on how an electric popcorn popper works, WikiHow takes you through the steps here.
Stove Top Popcorn Popper
Popping popcorn on the stove top is Ok as long as you use stainless steel. And, according to Non Toxic for Health, sticking with a stainless steel stove top popper is your best bet for non toxic popcorn. Therefore, you should stay clear of aluminum poppers and those that have plastic parts.
And, with the stove top method, it’s rather quick and easy, not to mention, fun. In addition, it is manual so you will be stirring the kernels as they’re popping.
It is important to note, though, the stove top method will require oil. So, this is not the healthiest option on our list.