Silicone baking mats make baking life so much quicker and hassle-free. This is because there’s very little cleanup. And, what cleanup there is, it takes little to no effort. So, this is why we went on the hunt for the best silicone baking mat. To make our lives easier and yours as well.
However, we wanted to make sure silicone baking mats were safe to use. And, this was our first inquiry into finding the best silicone baking mat.
Are silicone baking mats safe?
According to LIVESTRONG, chemical contamination isn’t a major issue with silicone bake-ware. In addition, most silicone baking mats can withstand heat as high as 450 degrees Fahrenheit. So, as long as you keep your baking under this range, you will avoid chemical transfer.
And, according to Wellness Mama, dangers of silicone are anecdotal and not scientifically backed, which doesn’t prove the safety of silicone. Furthermore, the potential of hazards occur when the silicone reaches high temperatures.
Therefore, at this point in time, as long as the silicone stays within the recommended temperature range, there is no evidence that silicone is harmful.
How durable are silicone baking mats?
The next question we had was, how durable are silicone baking mats? Well, they don’t rust, they don’t break, and like we stated above, they withstand extreme high temperatures. And, as long as you don’t sharpen your knife on them or use them as a cutting board, a quality silicone baking mat will last you a long time.
So, once we got our 2 major questions out of the way, we were ready for some cookies. So, we searched for the top rated silicone mats on the market and narrowed them down to the top 7 best silicone baking mats money can buy.
And, when we narrowed these picks down, we made sure to have a wide array of mats on our list. The best silicone baking mat for you may have measurements displayed on its facade. And, this is especially helpful when baking pies or needing a quick reference guide for conversions. Or, the best silicone baking mat for you may be a blank surface to utilize your creativity.
Finally, like we mentioned previously, our final picks have the highest reviews on the market. These reviews are from fellow bakers who know the ins and outs of a kitchen and who know what constitutes a really good silicone baking mat.
So, without further ado, it’s time for some cookies.
Best Silicone Baking Mat
Best Silicone Baking Mat
di Oro Living Pro Silicone Baking Mat
If you’re looking for baking motivation, this pick for best silicone baking mat has it as clear as that chocolate chip cookie you’ve been dreaming about. The di Oro Living Pro Silicone Baking Mat keeps things clear and concise with the words “BAKE IT” plastered on the front.
This silicone baking mat is professional grade with a 1 mm silicone and glass fiber platform. This is one of the thickest silicone baking mats on our list. And, a thicker mat tends to be stronger and last longer than their thinner counterparts. Furthermore, with the addition of glass fiber, this will provide extra durability.
The di Oro Living Pro Silicone Baking Mat is BPA free and FDA approved. Additionally, to keep things safe, this silicone baking mat can handle temperatures from -40 degrees Fahrenheit to 480 degrees Fahrenheit. This means you can freeze this silicone mat and you can bake just about anything.
This silicone baking mat is stain resistant and warp resistant. And, of course, it is non-stick and dishwasher safe. So, cleanup is a breeze.
Lastly, the di Oro Living Pro Silicone Baking Mat comes in a 2-pack and measures 16.5 inches long and 11.625 wide. And, these mats come with a silicone snap band storage system where you can roll these mats up and secure them for storing.
The di Oro Living Pro Silicone Baking Mats gets high reviews for quality and for being non stick. Consumers rave about how cookies slide right off of these mats.
In addition, consumers love how well these mats cleanup.
There’s not much bad you can say about these mats. Furthermore, the lack of negative reviews speaks volumes.
However, our job is to find something negative. So, if you’re looking for a silicone mat that has measurements, these mats are lacking a display of measurements.
Sili Bake The Original Silicone Pastry Baking Mat with Measurements
This next pick for best silicone baking mat displays the highly desirable measurements. These measurements include rulers in centimeters and inches which line all four sides of the mat. In addition, the center of the mat has pie measurements from 5 inches to 10 inches.
Furthermore, The Original Silicone Pastry Baking Mat by Sili Bake displays weight, oven temperature and liquid measurement conversions. And, that’s not all. The front of this mat displays a delicious sugar cookie recipe and a pie dough recipe.
This silicone baking mat is constructed of food grade silicone. This silicone is nontoxic, FDA approved and BPA free.
The Original Silicone Pastry Baking Mat by Sili Bake is safe to use at a temperature of up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. In addition to using it in the oven, this silicone mat is also safe to use in the freezer. And, can we say dishwasher? Yes, this mat is dishwasher safe.
This silicone baking mat measures 25 inches long by 15 inches wide. And, it is 0.4 millimeters thin. So, if you’re looking for a thin silicone baking mat, this is one to consider.
Lastly, once you’re finished baking, The Original Silicone Pastry Baking Mat by Sili Bake rolls up and fits inside a reusable protective case for easy storing.
This silicone baking mat has just about everything you need for baking, including the recipes and the measurements. If only it came with the flour, sugar and eggs, though. However, that might be asking for too much.
In addition, this silicone baking mat will always lay flat, no matter if it’s been rolled up for the past year.
This mat is very thin at 0.4 millimeters. So, it can be rather floppy and not as durable as some of our other picks. However, sometimes a thin silicone mat is a baker’s preference. So, what works for one, may not work for another and vice versa.
Silchef Silicone 3 Piece Non Stick Baking Mats
Silicone mats are like potato chips. You can’t have just one. So, it’s a great consideration to go for a pack of baking mats.
The Silchef Silicone 3 Piece Non Stick Baking Mats comes with 2 half-sheet mats and a 1/4-sheet liner. The half-sheet mats will line standard baking trays, while the 1/4-sheet liner will fit a baking tray intended for a toaster oven. However, with these mats, you can mix and match all sorts of different ways. For example, you can use a half-sheet mat with the 1/4-sheet liner for a batch of cookies. Of course, depending on the amount of cookies you will be baking.
These silicone baking mats are nontoxic, BPA approved, FDA approved and LFGB approved. Therefore, these mats are approved by both the US and German food handling laws.
And, the Silchef Silicone 3 Piece Non Stick Baking Mats are 1 millimeter thick. So, these mats will be more durable and last longer than their thinner counterparts.
These professional-grade silicone baking mats are constructed of silicone-coated fiberglass mesh. The fiberglass mesh will allow for better airflow and even heat distribution.
The Silchef Silicone 3 Piece Non Stick Baking Mats can reach temperatures as high as 484 degrees Fahrenheit and as low as -40 degrees Fahrenheit. This means you can go from the oven, to the freezer and to the dishwasher without transferring any toxins.
Finally, the 2 half-sheet mats measure 16.5 inches long and 11.625 inches wide. And, the 1/4-sheet liner measures 11.5 inches long and 8.5 inches wide.
These are one of the highest reviewed silicone mats on our list with thousands of consumers raving about these mats. And, more specifically, they rave about how non stick they are and how well they clean up.
While these mats do have rave reviews, there are a good amount of consumers who state that these mats don’t last very long. And, after a few months of use, they’ve experienced some heavy discoloration.
Silpat Premium Non-Stick Silicone Baking Mat
Ever dreamt of being a French pastry extraordinaire? Well, here’s your chance to practice with a high-quality, French silicone baking mat. Furthermore, this company claims they are the originators of the non-stick baking mat. So, looks like it’s a win-win.
The Silpat Premium Non-Stick Silicone Baking Mat is made of food-grade silicone with a fiberglass mesh. This fiberglass mesh will help improve airflow and promote even heat distribution. Furthermore, this fiberglass mesh will increase longevity since it increases the durability of the baking mat.
This pick for best silicone baking mat is FDA, NSF and Kosher certified. It is also nontoxic and BPA free.
The Silpat Premium Non-Stick Silicone Baking Mat is safe to use between -40 degrees Fahrenheit and 482 degrees Fahrenheit. Therefore, you can feel free to bake at your luxury and use in the freezer when it entails. Furthermore, this baking mat is dishwasher safe.
Lastly, this silicone baking mat measures 16.5 inches long and 11.625 inches wide. And, with this measurement, it works great for a pan that’s 18 inches long and 13 inches wide.
According to chefs, this silicone baking mat is the gold standard in professional kitchens, bakeries and patisseries. Furthermore, when cared for properly, most consumers found that these baking mats lasted for years.
There are quite a bit of reviews from consumers stating they received knockoffs. However, we did our investigative work and this is the real McCoy.
KITZINI Silicone Baking Mat Set of 2
This pick for best silicone baking mat is .75 millimeters thick. So, while it’s not the thickest mat on our list, it still has a decent thickness which will hold up nicely.
The KITZINI Silicone Baking Mat comes in a set of 2 which measure 16.5 inches long and 11.625 inches wide. And, these are sized to fit standard half sheet baking pans.
These silicone baking sheets are made with food grade silicone with a fiber glass core. This fiber glass core promotes durability and longevity. In addition, it will help to keep the surface evenly heated.
The KITZINI Silicone Baking Mat can withstand temperatures of up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit and temperatures as low as -40 degrees Fahrenheit. This temperature range makes these mats safe for the oven, as well as, the freezer.
Finally, and perhaps most importantly, these mats are BPA free and FDA approved.
The KITZINI Silicone Baking Mats get high ratings for how non stick they are and how easy they are to clean.
Like most silicone baking mats, they tend to leave a greasy film after baking. And, sometimes it’s hard to remove. That being said, some consumers don’t like how greasy these feel after use.
Folksy Super Kitchen Non-Slip Silicone Pastry Mat
This pick for best silicone baking mat is a pie baker’s dream. The Folksy Super Kitchen Non-Slip Silicone Pastry Mat displays pie crust measurements from 5 inches to 16 inches. And, this makes it easy to roll out your dough for the perfect pie crust.
This food grade silicone baking mat is BPA free, FDA certified and LFGB certified. This means it complies with the food handling laws of the US and Germany.
The Folksy Super Kitchen Non-Slip Silicone Pastry Mat is 0.7 millimeters thick. And, while this isn’t the thickest mat on our list, it’s not the thinnest, either. Therefore, if you’re looking for an in between, this is a great mat to consider.
This silicone baking mat is made with high quality silicone with a fiberglass mesh. This fiberglass mesh will transfer heat evenly and ensures the durability of the mat. Furthermore, the fiberglass mesh promotes airflow.
The Folksy Super Kitchen Non-Slip Silicone Pastry Mat can handle temperatures from -30 degrees Fahrenheit to a maximum of 470 degrees Fahrenheit. And, this mat is freezer and dishwasher safe.
Lastly, this silicone baking mat measures 28 inches long and 20 inches thick. Therefore, if you’re looking for an extra-large sized silicone baking mat, this is definitely one to consider.
The size of this is amazing. And, it’s not going to make you feel cramped or restricted.
Furthermore, it has a nice thickness to it. It’s not too thick, nor is it too thin. Just right.
Finally, consumers state that this mat is skid resistant which makes for a great platform for rolling out dough. And, it’s non stick and easy to clean as advertised.
The major con of this mat is it doesn’t fit standard sized baking sheets and it is also larger than standard sized restaurant baking sheets. Therefore, for the majority of us, this mat would best be used on the countertop for prepping ingredients.